Survey of Aluminum-Based Instantaneous
Discs Documenting the Radio Broadcasts
of Bing Crosby, 1949 - 1954

 

INTRODUCTION

The collection of Bing Crosby radio broadcasts on instantaneous discs in the Collection Deposit Library document Crosby's radio broadcasts from 1949 to 1954. For nearly 30 years (1931 - 1962) Crosby broadcast a variety show at least weekly (occasionally, five to six times a week) that ran from 15 minutes to an hour. Crosby would perform solo as well as with guests from the Hollywood silver screen and legends from the jazz and swing world, including Judy Garland, the Andrew Sisters, Jimmy Stewart, Duke Ellington, Louis Armstrong, Lucille Ball -- just to name a few.

chesterfield adCrosby prompted many innovations in the recording technology industry over his lifetime. Constrained by the demands of a live nightly and weekly radio broadcast that had to be repeated for different time zones, Crosby wanted to explore recorded radio programming. In 1945, he was hosting the Kraft Music Hour on NBC and implored the company to give him more funding and to allow him to pre-record his show on the 16 inch instantaneous discs that were gaining popularity and trust in the old time radio broadcast world. NBC denied Crosby the ability to pre-record his shows, and in protest Crosby quit the show in Fall 1945, only to be legally forced to fulfill his contract which ended May 1946. After his contract expired, Crosby left NBC for ABC -- a network that would allow him to broadcast pre-recorded shows. Crosby was also involved in the invention of magnetic audio tape. Germans developed audio tape technology during World War II, and several German tape recorders were brought back to the United States after the war and distributed to audio engineers so that they could imitate and improve upon the German technology. Crosby was contacted by John Mullin who demonstrated how audio tape technology worked, and on October 1, 1947 when Crosby hosted guest Gary Cooper, the first radio broadcast recorded and edited entirely on magnetic audio tape was aired. Crosby later went on to finance the beginnings of the Ampex corporation, renowned for years as innovators of magnetic audio tape technology in the United States.

Three shows cover the time period of the instantaneous disc collection -- the Philco Radio Time on ABC sponsored by Philco Radio and ran weekly for 30 minutes from 1946-1949. Next to come was the Chesterfield Show from 1949 to 1952, which also aired for 30 minutes weekly. General Electric sponsored another show documented in the collection which also aired 30 minutes week

Crosby-Clooney Show, CBS, 1960-62
Ford Road Show, CBS, 1957-59
The Bing Crosby Show, CBS, 1954-56
General Electric, CBS, 1952-54
Chesterfield, CBS, 1949-52
Philco Radio Time, ABC, 1946-49

Kraft Music Hall, NBC, 1935-46
Woodbury Soap, CBS, 1933-35
Chesterfield, CBS, 1932-33
The Cremo Singer, CBS, 1931-32
Unsponsored, CBS, 1931

The Collection / Instantaneous Disc Brands

Disc brands
for larger view click on image

The collection of Bing Crosby radio broadcasts in the Collections Deposit Library consists of 661 ten inch discs and 11 eight inch discs. Five brands of instantaneous disc are represented: Wilcox Gay Recordio Discs (WGRD), Presto, Duodisc, Audiodiscs, and Recoton. Of these brands, there are 4 types of WGRD (black coated with a blue label; red coated with a blue label, black coated with a green triangle label, and red coated with a blue triangle label), 2 types of Duodiscs (black coated and orange coated), and two types of Presto discs (black coated with two holes and black coated with 4 holes). The bulk of the collection is recorded on black coated / blue label WGRD and black coated Duodiscs. Red coated / blue label WGRD are the third most prevalent disc types, and there are only a few instances of the orange coated Duodiscs, the Audiodiscs, and the Recoton discs.

The discs are all have an aluminum base with a plastic outer coating – composed of either cellulose nitrate or cellulose nitrate. Without a chemical analysis (please see future plans for further discussion), I would speculate that the coating is cellulose acetate as the width is extremely thin and some of the records have a translucent orange or red coating. The black coated discs are noticeably thicker than the red or orange coated, and the Duodiscs are thicker than any other brand. Easily flexed, the discs are in remarkably good condition given their thinness, age, and the number of times and ways they have been transported and stored.
The records are stored upright on wooden shelves in very acidic paper sleeves.

A single show is recorded on up to seven sides of a record -- presumably, each song has its own record side. In the old time radio cirlce, these discs may be known better as radio phonographs.

 

 

 


METHODOLOGY

Time constraints did not permit a survey of all 669 records. Rather than perform a random sample -- the randomness of which would in some aspects impede the utilization of these findings in a survey of the complete collection -- the first 50 and last 50 (approximately 15%) of the records were examined. Record title, size, type, brand, and condition were documented, as well as any notes of damage. I photographed the various record labels and any problematic symptoms displayed by the discs. Although I only recorded information about 100 of the discs, I went through the discs one by one to generate a count, find the various brands, and quickly analyze condition.

 

RESULTS -- please click on images for larger versions

The disc collection is in remarkably good condition considering its age and disc types. Very few scratches were noted, and most discs seemed capable of playback given proper needles and turntables. Patterns of degradation do exist, however:


Exterior disc coating flaking off
On the black coated Duodisc (top left), the flaking side of the disc was an unrecorded blank (the other side had been used to record a broadcast and was in good condition. Bits of the black plastic coating were cracked and falling off with ease. This was the worst instance of damage documented. It was fascinating to think that the process of recording -- etching grooves into the plastic, might further bind the exterior layer to the aluminum base coat.
The orange Recoton disc (below, left) featured flaking around the perimeter of the disc. Several orange coated discs displayed this type of damage.

Cracks -- a preamble to flaking
Cracking of the exterior plastic coating was evident on many of the discs -- orange, red, and black, and most brands.

Bind separation - or rust?
This orange coated Duodisc is the only example of this sort of dicoloration, which is likely to be either the chemical degradation of the binder between the orange plastic coating and the aluminum base or the rusting of the aluminum base.

Plasticizer seeping?
A key characteristic of cellulose nitrate discs is the separtion of the castor oil which is used to plasticize nitrocellulose during the manufacture of the discs. This separation is manifested by the expulsion of the castor oil from the celluloe nitrate and the formation of a sticky, powder-like layer on the surface of discs. This sort of degradation only discovered on one disc.

Plasticizer seeping, part II?
Raised bumps were noticed on several of the red coated / blue label Wilcox Gay Recordio Discs, accompanied by a thin layer of some sort of emulsion-like residue. The bumps were heaviest towards the center of the recordable area of the discs.

 

I was not able to properly document the damage seemingly caused by light or air particulates on the discs. Many of the black coated discs displayed at their perimeter -- and particularly the edge facing the open sleeve of the disc envelope) a green-ish translucency (Duodisc) or a red-ish translucency (Wilcox Gay Recordio Discs). Also, while it not apparent that each disc had suffered damage from the highly acidic paper envelopes in which the discs are stored, it is of no doubt that the low pH provides a hostile, acidic environment which can only encourage further deterioration.

 

FUTURE PLANS

First I would like to identify the composition of the plastic (information containing) coating on the discs. Further, I would like to establish the composition of the red and orange discs versus the black discs and also explore the compenents of each brand's discs. Following the initiate of the patent survey, I would like to find patents relevant to the brands of discs in this collection. Such information may provide clues as to binder composition (what adheres the plastic coating to the aluminum base) as well as the chemical make up of fillers, extenders, and other additives. I would also like to measure the exact dimensions of thickness of the discs and compare the various types and brands.

I would like to share a completed survey with the Bing Crosby Internet Museum so that the contents of radio broadcasts could be verified (guests documented properly on the discs) and so that if at a later date this collection was given proper preservation attention and user as well as archival copies were made, a means to advertise the resource would be available. I would also like to research the existance and state of any Crosby broadcast discs formally housed in the archives of NBC, CBS, and ABC. I would also like to share the results of the survey with the Phonozoic's Recordio Project site which strives to document the different types and time periods of home recording discs.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Bing Crosby Internet Museum. Accessed online 24 April 2003. Helpful for background information on the life, pursuits, and radio broadcasts of Bing Crosby.

Day, Timothy. A Century of Recorded Music: Listening to Musical History. New Haven: Yale University Press, 2000.

Phonozoic Recordio Project: A Labelography of Home Recording Discs. Accessed online 20 April 2003.

 

 

 

Survey:

Title

date

size

type

brand

cond

notes

Bing Crosby,, Lindsey Crosby - 1/2

 

12-19-51

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

Wilcox-Gray Recordio Disc

surface spotting

MGW paper cover - very acidic - paper pieces flask e off on disc

Bing Crosby, Ella Fitzgerald - 5/6

11-28-51

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

WILCOX GAY RECORDIO DISC

surface spotting

Bing Crosby, Ella Fitzgerald - 3/4

11-28-51

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

WILCOX GAY RECORDIO DISC

 

 

Bing Crosby, Ella Fitzgerald - 1/2

11/28/51

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

WILCOX GAY RECORDIO DISC

 

 

Bing Crosby, Alexis Smith - 5/6

11-21-51

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

WILCOX GAY RECORDIO DISC

 

 

Bing Crosby, Alexis Smith - 3/4

11-21-51

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

WILCOX GAY RECORDIO DISC

glittery crystals

 

Bing Crosby, Alexis Smith - 1/2

11-21-51

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

WILCOX GAY RECORDIO DISC

crack in laminate

 

Bing Crosby, Jimmy Stewart - 4/5

11-14-51

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

WILCOX GAY RECORDIO DISC

 

1 side obvious tracks (4), other just one long track

Bing Crosby, Jimmy Stewart - 2/3

11/14/51

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

WILCOX GAY RECORDIO DISC

small bubbles - side 2

 

Bing Crosby, Jimmy Stewart - 2/3

3/19/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

scuffs, emulsions

tracks present

Bing Crosby, Jimmy Stewart - 1

Bing Crosby, Humphrey Bogart Lauren Bacall - 6

3/19/52,  3/12/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

 

Bing Crosby, Humphrey Bogart Lauren Bacall - 4/5

3/12/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

 

Bing Crosby, Humphrey Bogart Lauren Bacall - 2/3

3/12/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

 

Bing Crosby, Humphrey Bogart Lauren Bacall - 1

Bing Crosby, Bob Hope - 7

3/12/52,

3/11/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

 

Bing Crosby, Bob Hope - 5/6

3/11/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

 

Bing Crosby, Bob Hope - 3/4

3/11/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

 

Bing Crosby, Bob Hope - 1/2

3/11/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

 

Bing Crosby, Bob Crosby, Kathy Crosby - 5/6

3/6/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

 

Bing Crosby, Bob Crosby, Kathy Crosby - 3/4

3/6/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

 

Bing Crosby, Bob Crosby, Kathy Crosby - 1/2

3/6/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

 

Bing Crosby, Bell Sisters - 5/6

2/27/52

10

black coat aluminum base

WILCOX GAY RECORDIO DISC

emulsions spots

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Bell Sisters - 2/3

2/27/52

10

black coat aluminum base

WILCOX GAY RECORDIO DISC

emulsions spots

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Bell Sisters - 1/2

2/27/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Patti [Nills], [Daze Bros] - 5/6

2/20/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc

emulsions spots

 

Bing Crosby, Patti [Nills], [Daze Bros] - 3/4

2/20/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc

emulsions spots

 

Bing Crosby, Patti [Nills], [Daze Bros] - 1/2

2/20/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc

emulsions spots

 

Bing Crosby, Humphrey Bogart, Laurend Bacall - 5/6

2/13/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc

emulsions spots

 

Bing Crosby, Humphrey Bogart, Laurend Bacall - 3/4

2/13/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc

emulsions spots

 

Bing Crosby, Humphrey Bogart, Laurend Bacall - 1/2

2/13/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc

emulsions spots

 

Bing Crosby, Fred Astaire - 5/6

2/6/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc

emulsions spots

 

Bing Crosby, Fred Astaire - 3/4

2/6/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc

emulsions spots

 

Bing Crosby, Fred Astaire - 51/2

2/6/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc

emulsions spots

 

Bing Crosby, Patty Page, Bob Burns - 5/6

1-30-52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Patty Page, Bob Burns - 3/4

1-30-52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Patty Page, Bob Burns - 1/2

1-30-52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Paul Douglas -5/6

1/23/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Paul Douglas - 3/4

1/23/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Paul Douglas - 1/2

1/23/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Bob Hope - 5/6

1-16-52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Bob Hope - 3/4

1-16-52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Bob Hope - 1/2

1-16-52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Jimmy Boyd - 1

Bing Crosby, Gary Crosby - 7

3/5/53

12/25/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Gary Crosby - 3/4

12/25/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Gary Crosby - 1/2

12/25/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Peggy Lee - 5/6

6/25/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Peggy Lee - 3/4

6/25/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Peggy Lee - 1/2

6/25/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Peggy Lee - 3/4

6/18/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Peggy Lee - 3/4

6/18/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Rosemary Clooney - 5/6

6/11/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Rosemary Clooney - 3/4

6/11/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Judy Garland, Rosemary Clooney - 1/2

(**on same side)

6/4/52

6/11/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Judy Garland 4/5

6/4/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Judy Garland 2/3

6/4/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Judy Garland 1

Bing Crosby, Judy Garland 6

6/4/52

5/28/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Judy Garland 4/5

5/28/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Judy Garland 2/3

5/28/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Judy Garland 1

Bing Crosby, Judy Garland 6

5/28/52

5/21/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Judy Garland 4/5

5/21/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Judy Garland 2/3

5/21/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Judy Garland 1

Bing Crosby, David Niven 5

5/21/52

5/14/52

10 inch

black coat aluminum base

Duodisc Aluminum Base

good

single track sides

------

 

 

 

 

 

 

Bing Crosby, Betty Grable, Harry James 5/6

1/5/49

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Betty Grable, Harry James 3/4

1/5/49

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Betty Grable, Harry James 1/2

1/5/49

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, [Nills Beefer] Peggy Lee - 5

Bing Crosby, Johnny Mercer, Peggy Lee - 5

12/29/48

1/12/49

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Johnny Mercer - 3/4

1/12/49

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Johnny Mercer - 1/2

1/12/49

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Gary Crosby Gary Cooper - 5/6 --

3/8/50

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, .Gary Crosby, Gary Cooper - 7

Bing Crosby, (The) Twins, Philip & Dennis - 1

3/8/50

3/15/50

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, (The) Twins, Philip & Dennis - 2/3

3/18/50

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, (The) Twins, Philip & Dennis - 3/4

3/18/50

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, (The) Twins, Philip & Dennis - 6

Bing Crosby, Ethel Merman, Hop - a - long Cassidy -- 1

3/18/50

3/22/50

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Ethel Merman, Hop - a - long Cassidy - 2/3

3/22/50

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

good

single track sides

Bing Crosby, Ethel Merman, Hop - a - long Cassidy - 4/5

 

10 inch

red coat aluminum base

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

good

single track sides

ÒWe the PeopleÓ with Bing Crosby, as Mr. Music

blank - 2

12/28/50

 

black coated aluminum disc

Duodisc

recorded side - good.  blank side - flaking, cracks.  see pic

 

Bing Crosby, Claudette Colbert - 7

ÒWe the PeopleÓ Bing Crosby, as Mr. Music  -- 1

10/25/50

12/28/50

10 inch

black coated aluminum disc

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green w/ brown)

slight emulsion

sing

Bing Crosby, Louis Armstrong,  Dinah Shore 6/7

12/27/50

 

red coated aluminum disc

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (blue)

good

sing

Bing Crosby, Louis Armstrong,  Dinah Shore 4/5

12/27/50

 

red coated aluminum disc

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (blue)

good

sing

Bing Crosby, Louis Armstrong,  Dinah Shore 2/3

12/27/50

 

red coated aluminum disc

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (blue)

good

sing

ÒChesterfieldÓ Bing Crosby, Jimmy Stewart - 4/5

1/24/51

10

black coated aluminum disc

duodisc

thick powdery material on one side, good on other; print through from wrapper obvious in powdery side

 

Bing Crosby, Beatrice Lillie - 4/5

4/26/50

10 inch

black coated aluminum disc

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri  / brown)

good

tracks

Bing Crosby, Ella Fitzgerald, Al Jolson - 1

Bing Crosby, Beatrice Lillie - 6

5/3/50

4/26/50

10

black coated aluminum disc

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri, brown)

good - red at perimeter exposed to light at top

tracks

Bing Crosby, Ella Fitzgerald, Al Jolson - 2/3

 

5/03/50

10 inch

black coated aluminum disc

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (gr tri / br

good

 

Bing Crosby, Ella Fitzgerald, Al Jolson - 4/5

 

5/03/50

10 inch

black coated aluminum disc

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (gr tri / br

good

 

Bing Crosby, Ella Fitzgerald, Al Jolson - 6/7

 

5/03/50

10 inch

black coated aluminum disc

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (gr tri / br

good

 

Bing Crosby, Louis Armstrong, Jack [Seazarkson] - 4/5

3/16/49

10 inch

red coated aluminum disc

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

good

 

Bing Crosby, Louis Armstrong, Jack [Seazarkson] - 2/3

3/16/49

10 inch

red coated aluminum disc

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

good

 

Bing Crosby, Ethel Merman - 5/6

3/23/49

10 inch

red coated aluminum disc

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

slight bubbling

 

Bing Crosby, Ethel Merman - 3/4

3/23/49

10 inch

red coated aluminum disc

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (green tri)

emulsion

 

Bing Crosby, Jimmy Stewart - 5/6

4/6/49

10 inch

black coated aluminum disc

Wilcox Gay Recordio Disc (blue tri)

good

tacks